HeadlessEC (GraphQL) not yet compatible with Bagisto 2.1.2?

tmss

Good day.

I saw that HeadlessEC (GraphQL) is not compatible with Bagisto 2.1.2.
https://forums.bagisto.com/topic/3592/problem-with-install-graphql?_=1716859776791

I am thinking that if I want to do something like HeadlessEC (separation of front and back) with Bagisto 2.1.2, I might be able to do it by using Bagisto APIs 2.0.0 and communicating via API.

However, the Laravel Sanctum reference states the following

https://readouble.com/laravel/10.x/ja/sanctum.html

Note: Do not use API tokens to authenticate your own first-party SPA. Instead, use Sanctum's built-in SPA authenticator.

It appeared that Bagisto APIs did not use SPA authentication.

Is it safe to do something like HeadlessEC (separation of front and back) with Bagisto APIs for security purposes?

And why is it secure with GraphQL?

Rishabh-Webkul

Hello @tmss

If you want to make Bagisto2.0 (GraphQL) compatible to the latest version Bagisto 2.1.2((GraphQL)) go to

vendor >> bagisto >> graphql-api >> src >> Models >> CatalogRule >> CatalogRule.php

this file and make a slight change in these two functions i.e. catalog_rule_products() and catalog_rule_product_prices() and apply return type HasMany as shown in the below image.

Thanks & Regards..!!

tmss

@Rishabh-Webkul

Thanks for the confirmation.
This was already in place, but it did not work.

I was getting this error at the time and it looked like some CLASS was missing.

ERROR: Failed to find class Webkul\CMS\Models\CmsPageTranslation in namespaces [App, Webkul\GraphQLAPI\Models] for directive @paginate.{" exception":""[object] (Nuwave\Lighthouse\\Exceptions\\DefinitionException(code: 0): Failed to find class

Rishabh-Webkul

Hello @tmss

May I know in which Bagisto version you are making these changes ?

Also, read the complete readme file of headless e-commerce regarding the installation

https://github.com/bagisto/headless-ecommerce

Thanks & Regards..!!

tmss

@Rishabh-Webkul

Thank you very much.

I was reading the same material.
https://github.com/bagisto/headless-ecommerce

The version of Bagisto is 2.1.2.

What I want to do is.

to run headless-ecommerce.
2.I am trying to develop a package in "bagisto/packages" without touching the source of Bagisto itself.

Rishabh-Webkul

Hello @tmss

We have also provided a video tutorial to install this

https://youtu.be/kdHTm30GvwI?si=OThfOZYDBm5IGg7W

kindly check the link to learn in detail video from 5:14 minutes inside this video.

Thanks & Regards..!!

tmss

@Rishabh-Webkul

Thanks for the video!

I have GraphQL as a package though,
https://github.com/bagisto/headless-ecommerce
Is this the same as what you are doing on this page?

If I install it with a command that references GitHub

It will be downloaded in bagisto/vendor/bagisto/graphql-api.
No packages were added to bagisto/packages/Webkul.

Also, should I use an older version?
From the video, it looks like the following versions

Bagisto:v1.4.3
Headless EC (GraphQL):v1.4.3
nextjs-commerce:v1 branch

I am currently using 2.1.2 of Bagisto.

By the way, the following versions worked as shown in the image

Bagisto:2.0.0
Headless EC:dev-master

What is the safest and most stable way to use HeadlessEC?
Is it preferable to use 1.4.3 as shown in the video?

I would like to use something that is stable in its documentation and specifications and that I can safely update in the future.

I am experimenting with various versions and am confused.
Sorry for the inconvenience.

Rishabh-Webkul

Hello @tmss

Greetings of the day..!

This is an example of bagisto1.4.3 you can install it with the latest version with the instruction present in READ ME file.

https://github.com/bagisto/headless-ecommerce

Thanks & Regards..!

tmss

@Rishabh-Webkul

I see!
I will try Bagisto 2.1.2

Thank you for your help

Rishabh-Webkul

Hello @tmss

You're Welcome. If, you like our support kindly give 5-star reviews here from the link below
It will be grateful for us.

https://www.trustpilot.com/review/bagisto.com

Thanks & Regards..!!

tmss

Thank you for the video!
I was very careful and it did not work.

Sorry for the many sentences!

I tried to install HeadlessEC(GraphQL) by referring to the video (v1.4.3), v1.4.3 and v2.0.1 README.md and comparing them.

Compared to v2.0.1, the following seemed to be necessary in summary, so I performed the following

put Headless EC(GraphQL) under Packages
(I ultimately found this unnecessary)
setup Headless EC v2.0.1 according to README.md *1

https://github.com/bagisto/headless-ecommerce/blob/v2.0.1/README.md

*1 There are no steps to configure config/lighthouse.php

I ran it and it didn't work.
I have a question about README.md of v1.4.3 and differences between v1.4.3 Video and v2.0.1 README.md, etc. I would appreciate it if you could check.

■Questions.
1.
I tried to install Headless EC on Bagisto 2.1.2 with the following

Result: Failure error
composer require bagisto/graphql-api:2.0.1
composer require bagisto/graphql-api:2.0.0

Result: Success
composer require bagisto/graphql-api dev-main

I can only install dev-main, is this normal?
Can I continue to use this in production?

1.
 Symfony\Component\ErrorHandler\Error\FatalError 

  Declaration of Webkul\GraphQLAPI\Models\CatalogRule\CatalogRule::catalog_rule_products() must be compatible with Webkul\CatalogRule\Models\CatalogRule::catalog_rule_products(): Illuminate\Database\Eloquent\Relations\HasMany

  at vendor/bagisto/graphql-api/src/Models/CatalogRule/CatalogRule.php:14
     10▕ {
     11▕     /**
     12▕      * Get the Catalog rule Product that owns the catalog rule.
     13▕      */
  ➜  14▕     public function catalog_rule_products()
     15▕     {
     16▕         return $this->hasMany(CatalogRuleProductProxy::modelClass());
     17▕     }
     18


2.

   Whoops\Exception\ErrorException 

  Declaration of Webkul\GraphQLAPI\Models\CatalogRule\CatalogRule::catalog_rule_products() must be compatible with Webkul\CatalogRule\Models\CatalogRule::catalog_rule_products(): Illuminate\Database\Eloquent\Relations\HasMany

  at vendor/bagisto/graphql-api/src/Models/CatalogRule/CatalogRule.php:14
     10▕ {
     11▕     /**
     12▕      * Get the Catalog rule Product that owns the catalog rule.
     13▕      */
  ➜  14▕     public function catalog_rule_products()
     15▕     {
     16▕         return $this->hasMany(CatalogRuleProductProxy::modelClass());
     17▕     }
     18▕ 

3.
Script @php artisan package:discover --ansi handling the post-autoload-dump event returned with error code 255

Please let me know which combination of Bagisto and HeadlessEC (GraphQL) can be used as a stable version.

Currently, it's not clear what version is compatible with what,
I am trying various versions.

I am very confused.
My goal is to use HeadlessEC(GraphQL) with Bagisto v2.1.2.

I saw on Github that Headless EC(GraphQL) v2.0.1 only works with Bagisto v2.0.0.
This time I was told that Bagisto v2.1.2 could be used, so I tried again, but it still did not work.

Is it correct that there is no way to use Headless EC(GraphQL) v2.0.1 with Bagisto v2.1.2?
(The HasMany fixes have already been applied but did not work).

The error in Laravel is always the same as below.
I also looked here and it seems that some CLASS files do not exist.

local.ERROR: Failed to find class Webkul\CMS\Models\CmsPage in namespaces [App, Webkul\GraphQLAPI\Models] for directive @paginate. {"exception":"[object] (Nuwave\\Lighthouse\\Exceptions\\DefinitionException(code: 0): Failed to find class Webkul\\CMS\\Models\\CmsPage in namespaces [App, Webkul\\GraphQLAPI\\Models] for directive @paginate. at /var/www/html/bagisto/vendor/nuwave/lighthouse/src/Schema/Directives/BaseDirective.php:190)

I don't think I need to manually put graphql-api in pakages/Webkul in v.2.0.1, is that correct?

The result of the installation with the command,
I thought that I don't need to put it in pakages/Webkul again because it is in bagisto/vendor/bagisto/graphql-api.

bagisto/vendor/bagisto/graphql-api/composer.json
This is also why there is also the following statement in

    "autoload": {
            "psr-4": {
                "Webkul\\GraphQLAPI\\": "src/"
            }
        },

bagisto/config/lighthouse.php
I believe it can also be referenced in namespaces in

(It should also automatically integrate with bagisto/composer.json)

I only found in the video about adding to bagisto/config/app.php providers.
*Not mentioned in README.md.

Webkul\GraphQLAPI\Providers\GraphQLAPIServiceProvider::class,

Is this one still required in v2.0.1?
I found this, so I don't believe it is currently needed.
(It is loaded by extra (discovery function))

bagisto/vendor/bagisto/graphql-api/composer.json

    "extra": {
            "laravel": {
                "providers": [
                    "Webkul\\GraphQLAPI\\Providers\\GraphQLAPIServiceProvider"
                ],
                "aliases": {}
            }
        },

In the video, I had first placed the package I had DL'd from GitHub myself under bagisto/packages/Webkul,
In addition, I did the following command,

composer require bagisto/graphql-api
php artisan bagisto_graphql:install

I don't think it's necessary, since it's a double configuration under the vendor, but is it necessary?
I'm sorry if I'm wrong.

vendor
bagisto/packages/Webkul

I feel it will be difficult to manage version upgrades in the future if I put them in two separate files.

As of v2.0.1, I don't put packages that I downloaded from GitHub under bagisto/packages/Webkul.
Is this correct?